So after reading several lengthy threads about what size hoodie to get and how they match up to the t-shirts, I ordered an XL hoodie (normally wear a large t-shirt) and crossed my fingers. Got this in the mail today, and it looks good--but it's also obviously way too big! I can wear a regular-fitting zip-up hoodie under it with plenty of room to spare, and the bottom of the hoodie falls to my upper thighs. I haven't washed it yet but I don't think it'll shrink so much that it'll magically fit!

So if anyone out there has found their large hoodie to be too small, wanna trade? Otherwise this puppy may have to go back to Chicago...